DIY Magic Erasers: How to Make Your Own for Less

If you love a good Magic Eraser but do not love the cost. You can try to make your own. These DIY magic erasers are just for you! Keep reading.

make your own magic eraser - Hand in yellow rubber glove cleaning toilet with magic eraser

If you love finding simple ways to save money around the house, you know that sometimes the smallest changes can make a big difference in your household budget. Cleaning supplies are one of those everyday expenses that can add up quickly, especially when you are constantly restocking your favorite products. One item that seems to disappear from my cleaning supply stash faster than I would like is the Magic Eraser.

Magic Erasers are wonderful for tackling stubborn marks, scuffs, crayon, and everyday messes that regular cleaning cloths just don’t seem to handle. The only downside? Buying them regularly can get a little expensive. And when there is a way to get the same cleaning benefits for less, I am always willing to give it a try!

That is where this easy DIY Magic Eraser idea comes in. Instead of spending money on name-brand cleaning sponges, you can make your own at home using an inexpensive alternative. It is a simple little household hack that can help stretch your cleaning budget without sacrificing a clean home.

Whether you are trying to cut back on household expenses, love a good DIY cleaning project, or simply enjoy discovering new ways to save money, this is one trick you will want to add to your cleaning routine. Let me show you how to make your own Magic Erasers at home and save a little money along the way!

How to Make a Homemade Magic Eraser

Did you know that Magic Erasers are made from a material called melamine foam? This unique foam has been used for a variety of commercial purposes, including soundproofing and insulation. Today, it is also widely used as a cleaning tool because of its ability to tackle stubborn marks, scuffs, and everyday messes.

Here is something I wish I had figured out years ago: You can buy melamine foam without purchasing the name-brand Magic Eraser! That’s right. You can skip the brand-name packaging and purchase the same basic cleaning material for a fraction of the cost.

Once I discovered this, I started buying melamine foam in bulk instead of continually purchasing individual Magic Erasers. It is such a simple way to save money on something I use regularly around my home.

Which Melamine Foam Should You Buy?

Over the years, I have tried several different sellers offering melamine foam. Unfortunately, not all of them have been worth purchasing. Some sponges were too stiff, while others fell apart almost as soon as I started cleaning. Needless to say, I went through quite a few before finding one I liked!

Not all melamine foam is created equal, so finding a product that holds up during cleaning makes a difference. The melamine foam I have been ordering over the last couple of years has worked well for me. While you might occasionally find a sponge or two that isn’t perfect, the overall quality and quantity make it a good value for the price.

You can find the melamine foam I purchase on Amazon here. I have found that buying these cleaning sponges in larger quantities is often a much better value than purchasing individual name-brand Magic Erasers.

And if you ever find yourself running out of Magic Erasers, you will know exactly where to find an affordable replacement!

If purchasing melamine foam in bulk isn’t in your budget right now, don’t worry. There are also ways to make your own homemade Magic Eraser alternative using a simple DIY approach. I’ll share more about that below.

Homemade Magic Eraser Recipe Mix

This is a soft wash mixture that will help with your home cleaning. If I do not have any melamine foam sponges, I use this as a replacement. I use a regular kitchen scrub to do the heavy work.

What you will need

2 tsp Borax
1 tsp Baking soda
1/4 cup of hot water
1 cleaning sponge

Instructions for Magic Eraser Mix

Mix the items above in a small bowl. Make sure that the borax is completely dissolved before using it. Then you can dip your sponge and use this mix to get those hard-to-remove marks and stains off your walls and floors.

Or you can spray your mixture either right on the surface you want to clean or directly onto the sponge. Scrub with your DIY Magic Eraser and formula just as you would with a store-bought Magic Eraser.

Please note: If your walls are painted, you may want to test this application in an inconspicuous spot before using it all over.